COUNTRY:

France

CITY:

Nantes

YEAR:

2011

PRIZE:

2012

Views of Embankment and Concrete Structures. An existing space residual space under the surface of the city (product of construction of 18, 19, 20 centuries port embankments will be adapted as the core space of the Memorial. The tidal effect makes the Loire River change its level about 4 m daily. Images are low tide. © Julian Bonder

BEFORE

images  (29)

AFTER
 

description

previous state

In the eighteenth century the river port of Nantes was a main departure point for French slave-trading expeditions. The ships took part in the “triangular trade” slave-trade system between the Atlantic coasts of Europe, Africa and the Caribbean or American colonies. A good part of the city’s wealth derived from this cruel activity and is displayed in the sumptuous palaces constructed by families engaged in the trade.

The Quai de la Fosse, a wharf that occupies the right bank of the Loire between the Anne de Bretagne Bridge and the Victor Schoelcher footbridge was the setting of the port’s main activity. Oblivious to the views over the river, people used its surface as an open-air car park until recently. Its surface concealed a triangular-shaped structure of reinforced concrete resting on top of an eighteenth-century quay wall. The rising waters of the river meant that the space was partially submerged every day.

aim of the intervention

The city turned its back on the memory of its shameful relationship with the slave trade until 1990 when an exhibition brought it explicitly to public attention. Some years later, the City Council earmarked seven and a half million euros for the transformation of the Quai de la Fosse into a space devoted to reflection on this history of slavery, commemoration of its abolition and making known the ongoing struggles against present-day forms of slavery. The intervention also aimed to improve the city’s relationship with the river.

description

The open-air car park has been transformed into a riverside walk of some three hundred and fifty metres in length. Encrusted in its paving are plaques with inscriptions of the names of the almost two thousand expeditions of French slavers, with the dates of departure and the ports from which they set sail, half of them from Nantes. All of them bear the words “Navire Négrier” (Slave Ship) as an explicit reminder of the purpose of these expeditions.

The ground-level path offers access to a lower level where the pre-existing triangular-shaped spaces have been protected from rising river waters by means of a waterproof concrete basin. The construction of the space required complex engineering work which had to be programmed according to the rising and falling river waters. The resulting space is a gallery of trapezoidal section as a result of the meeting of the angled portals of the structure, the wall of the eighteenth-century embankment and the slab of the upper esplanade. The form of this section coincidentally evokes the hold of a slave ship, a cramped effect that is reinforced by the narrowness and partially submerged position of the gallery.

This meaningful coincidence coherently reinforces the sense of the Memorial gallery, which has an information area, an exhibition space devoted to the history of slave trading and the different struggles against slavery until the present day. The museum facilities are complemented with the exhibition rooms of the recently refurbished Château des Ducs de Bratagne and organised tours through the city showing, among other features the luxurious residences of the old slave traders.

assessment

With this intervention, Nantes has been endowed with a public space imbued with ethical sense which sheds light on one of the most reprehensible periods of its past. The transformative ambition of a work that offers the city a new riverside walk transcends physical dimensions in order to attend to the political dimension. The significant coincidence of architectural form and content goes beyond a mere act of constriction to adopt a civic commitment to the defence of human rights.

David Bravo Bordas, architect

Comment and vote the work

Vote
Average rating: 4.3 / Votes: 56
 
Comments

We shall publish your views on-line as soon as possible. All comments will be reviewed by a moderator in order to avoid abuse. Thank you for participating.

Send your comment »
Please type the text presented in the image:
 

technical sheet

CITY: Nantes (284,677 inhabitants)

COUNTRY: France

BEGINING YEAR: 2003

BEGINING OF WORK YEAR: 2010

END OF WORK YEAR: 2011

AREA: 8,500 m2

COST: 7,500,000 €

WEBSITE: memorial.nantes.fr

credits

DEVELOPER:

Nantes Metropole, Ville de Nantes

AUTHORS:

Krzysztof Wodiczko & Julian Bonder Krzysztof Wodiczko & Julian Bonder. Wodiczko+Bonder, Architecture, Art & Design

COLLABORATORS:

Collaborators Thomas Long, design & visualization, graphic design (2003-2011) Design Team Snehal Intwala, Nicholas Capone, James Shen, Ryan McClain, Bill Panasuik Research Emmanuelle Chérel (2001-2004) Landscape Consultants Maximo Rohm, Ron Henderson, Michael Blier Glass Consultants James Carpenter, James Carpenter Design Associates, New York (preliminary design) Philippe Bompas & Nicolo Baldassini, RFR, Paris (design development) Technical Consultant Patrick Charles, architect/professor of architectural technology, Roger Williams University, Bristol, RI. Historical Advisors Sven Beckert, Harvard University Walter Johnson, Harvard University Vincent Brown, Duke University David Blight, Gilder Lehrman Center for the Study Slavery, Resistance & Abolition, Yale University Kirk Savage, professor, Pittsburgh University Olivier Pétré-Grenouilleau, professeur, membre du groupe Histoire et Géographie de l’Inspection générale de l’Éducation Nationale Photographer Philippe Ruault Ville de Nantes et Nantes Métropole Jean-Marc Ayrault, député-maire de Nantes Yannick Guin, conseiller municipal Octave Cestor, conseiller municipal Jean-Louis Jossic, adjoint à la culture Marie-Hélène Jouzeau, directrice Patrimoine et tourisme Irène Girardot, service Patrimoine et Tourisme Jean-Pierre Brindel, directeur Atelier urbain, Nantes Métropole Aurélie Roger, directeur projets Atelier urbain, Nantes Métropole Hervé Guégan, chef de projets, Atelier urbain, Nantes Métropole Comité de pilotage (dans sa première constitution) Yannick Guin, adjoint à la Culture, Jean-Marie Pousseur, adjoint à l’Urbanisme, Yvon Chotard, adjoint aux Coopérations internationales, Patrick Rimbert, adjoint aux Grands projets urbains, Octave Cestor et Jean-Louis Jossic, conseillers municipaux. Les membres des associations du Collectif du 150e anniversaire de l’abolition de l’esclavage, dont Joël Barreau (Nantes-Histoire), Jean-Michel Macabre, Michel Cocotier, Christian Vagao (Mémoire de l’Outre-mer) et Métisse à Nantes. Les experts : Norbert Duffort, conseiller aux arts plastiques de la DRAC Pays de la Loire, Alain Toumaire, architecte des Bâtiments de France, service départemental de l’Architecture et du Patrimoine, Robert Fleck, directeur de l’ERBAN, Bernard et Clotilde Barto, architectes, Michel Cantal-Dupart, architecte. Les services de la Ville de Nantes (dans leur configuration 2001-2004) Benoist Pavageau, directeur général des Services, Pierre-François Parodi, directeur du Cabinet du maire, Jean-Louis Bonnin, directeur général à la Culture, Mathieu Baradeau, directeur de la Communication externe, Jean-Pierre Brindel, directeur du service de l’Espace public, Geneviève Chigniac et Suzanne Le Gal, service Patrimoine et Tourisme, la Mission Centre-ville, les services de Nantes Métropole. Maître d’oeuvre Arcadis (Francois Bailly, Gildas Le Gall, Bruno Vasseur), Roulleau Architectes (Michel Roulleau, Jean-Marie Beslou)